Wow, really arrogant and stubbon people on here.
Nobody want's criticism and nobody might think that a hint of doing things a bit different could be a good idea??
Oh well, each to their own.
the great soundcloud debate...
- patrick bateman
- mnml maxi
- Posts: 5432
- Joined: Mon Feb 07, 2005 10:02 am
- Location: Copenhagen Denmark
- Contact:
What's the point in someone criticizing though if you're happy with the track yourself? It's just an opinion that might sway you off from liking your own music.
Again going back to the demo thing. We get demos sent. I say its cool, but not feeling certain aspects. They want to know exactly what bits I don't like, so they can change it into something I do. I just cant get down with this... its the most unattractive thing ever when someone does that. They obviously were happy with it enough to send a demo. To me people are not making music for themselves anymore and this is the problem.
Again going back to the demo thing. We get demos sent. I say its cool, but not feeling certain aspects. They want to know exactly what bits I don't like, so they can change it into something I do. I just cant get down with this... its the most unattractive thing ever when someone does that. They obviously were happy with it enough to send a demo. To me people are not making music for themselves anymore and this is the problem.
- patrick bateman
- mnml maxi
- Posts: 5432
- Joined: Mon Feb 07, 2005 10:02 am
- Location: Copenhagen Denmark
- Contact:
Being happy doesn't mean it's perfect and a good idea might be worth trying out. I'm not talking about changing a track completely but maybe there was something that could be enhanced. Who knows.::BLM:: wrote:What's the point in someone criticizing though if you're happy with the track yourself? It's just an opinion that might sway you off from liking your own music.
But saying from the beginning, fck you all, I would rather like you not comment on my tracks because I'm the master of house music, so just love me, is a bit stupid IMO.
This I agree to, but I don't see that hit has anything to do with getting advices on tracks you post your webpage/soundcloud/from friends etc.::BLM:: wrote: Again going back to the demo thing. We get demos sent. I say its cool, but not feeling certain aspects. They want to know exactly what bits I don't like, so they can change it into something I do. I just cant get down with this... its the most unattractive thing ever when someone does that. They obviously were happy with it enough to send a demo. To me people are not making music for themselves anymore and this is the problem.
Who said that though?But saying from the beginning, fck you all, I would rather like you not comment on my tracks because I'm the master of house music, so just love me, is a bit stupid IMO.
Just for me from my experience whenever I have got feedback it’s always been 'I don’t like the sound of that synth' which really never helped me so now I prefer to not get any because I never found that it helped. It's nice of course to get it when it’s nice, but really that’s only for your ego and nothing else.
-
- mnml maxi
- Posts: 2556
- Joined: Wed Apr 19, 2006 1:38 am
- Contact: