i think this is what i was trying to say,livecollective wrote: As for the deepness of doing what you like... Yes there is something deep about choice, but what I am saying is we are choosing to do something its a far cry from it being a huge part of your life. You could just as easily decide that in fact did not like what you previously thought you did. In this example what you like (music or style whatever) its expendable to you. Music to many cultures is not a choice but rather a solid, unchanging part of their life. Its closer to religion than something to do for FUN.
i sometimes feel that a lot of our music is a random collage of sounds put together in an atmosphere of hedonism and almost instantly disposable.
many years ago i had the pleasure and honour to be in the presence of Tibetan monks doing their thing (you know the guys with the deep voices and huge long horns)
what they do is increadible. they can sing notes 2 octaves lower than any opera singer, and they are the only humans capable of singing chords.
they usually use the same notes, a low C which they 'sing' with their chest cavity, a harmonic 2 octaves and a third higher which they sing with their throats, and a harmonic 2 octaves and a fifth higher which they sing with their nasal cavity.
i've heard it takes these guys over 20 years to perfect the technique and the effect is unbelievable when you hear it in the flesh. it resonates your whole being, and kind of puts you in a trance. its magical.
but there is absolute purpose to it, they arent just doing it for fun.
i'm not coming down on western culture en masse, although i have reservations about our direction, i just worry that some of the music that comes out of our scene has little real substance to it.
i dont want to be negative... but i know that sometimes i get an empty feeling from some western music... i cant help feeling that.